Starting from the often cited argument that right-wing populist parties 'hijack' religion to advance their political agenda, this paper aims to take a closer look at the changing relationship of the populist radical right (PRR) to religion(s) in Switzerland and Austria. While the notion of the appropriation of religion by populist radical right (PRR) parties is compelling, this analysis argues that religion cannot be so easily 'hijacked' in a unilateral way. Instead, religious groups actively engage in the political process on the basis of shared ideological positions, particularly on issues such as sexual identity and gender diversity rights, including reproductive health or equality for LGBTQIA+ people. In both Switzerland and Austria, religious groups have historically worked with PRR parties when their views on anti-genderism and anti-Muslim sentiment coincided. In contrast, mainstream Christian churches have rejected partnerships with the PRR and criticised the use of religious slogans and identity markers. Recent events, however, suggest a shift away from the PRR's use of religious references. The paper therefore examines the relationship between the PRR and religion in Switzerland and Austria, taking stock of recent developments. By analysing party manifestos, speeches and electoral strategies from the last 20 years, it contributes to a deeper understanding of the evolving dynamics between religion and populist radical right movements in Western Europe.