Queer theologies challenge classical and recent Christian feminist theologies in many ways, most fundamentally in respect to (more or less) hidden assumptions of binarities such as male / female, mind / body, culture / nature and to stereotypes of female identity associated with these binarities. This paper works out the transformative and liberative potentials of queer criticism for future feminist theologies by addressing an ambivalent topic of feminist theology often impregnated with binarities and stereotypes: motherhood. It sketches a liberation theology of motherhood which not only includes non-conformative ways of mothering but builds upon them as being specific forms of embodied theology. Thus, the paper also challenges problematic alliances between stereotypes of „true" motherhood and traditionalist Christian belief systems, showing the democratic potential within a diversity-sensitive theology of doing motherhood. Furthermore, the paper aims at opening up an intertheological discussion on queering motherhood in various religions.