Despite being present for almost a century in Hungary, Jehovah's Witnesses have only received legal recognition in 1989. Experiencing the suffering of the Second World War, the oppression and persecution under the Communist Regime, and now dealing with the effects of a rapidly changing, technologically advancing postmodern, in some respects post-truth world, and seeing the current conflicts just beyond the North-Eastern borders of their country, the Hungarian Witnesses' community formed a unique self-understanding, specific to the Central-Eastern European region. Based on a research project, co-conducted with András Máté-Tóth between 2022 and 2024, my contribution aims to contextualize the presence of the Witnesses' community in contemporary Hungarian society, outlining its status, its members' collective identity and self-perception, and aspects of religious identity, specific to this "old new religion" in Hungary. Conducting the project in collaboration with the World Headquarters of Jehovah's Witnesses and the Hungarian Head Office, our inquiry was able to collect, structure, and analyze a never-before-seen sum of data on Jehovah's Witnesses. Based on the findings of a survey with over 9,000 valid responses and 35 recorded lifetime interviews summing up more than 60 hours of recorded and transcribed material with dedicated, long-standing Hungarian Witnesses, we created a unique dataset. Based on its evaluation, I will argue that there are themes within Hungarian Witnesses that align with the involved generations. Their experiences differ drastically, and their identities, self-perceptions, and even lived forms of religiosity call for a more diverse and structured framework. My paper will introduce one such framework, specifically calibrated to the CEE region and to the Hungarian Witnesses.